“Broken Hearted Lover” was written by Alton Delmore of the Delmore Brothers, the Alabama duo whose close harmony shaped country and early bluegrass. The Delmores recorded it around 1940.
The song is a plain, aching heartbreak number. The one the singer loves no longer loves him, and he can find no happiness in that knowledge; the lyric reaches for extremes, declaring he would sooner swim the ocean than go on as a broken-hearted lover.
The Delmore Brothers’ songs moved easily into bluegrass, suited to duet harmony.