- Dudley Connell — Lead Vocals, Guitar
- David McLaughlin — Mandolin
- Richard Underwood — Banjo
- Eddie Stubbs — Fiddle
- Larry Robbins — Bass
“Tragic Love” comes from the Stanley Brothers’ first year on Mercury. Carter and Ralph Stanley recorded it in Nashville on April 5, 1955, at Bradley Studios under producer Dee Kilpatrick, with a Clinch Mountain Boys lineup of Jim Williams on mandolin, Joe Meadows on fiddle and Bill Lowe on bass, Carter on guitar and Ralph on banjo. Mercury held the side back for three years and released it in 1958 on Country Pickin’ and Singin’, the label’s first full Stanley Brothers album, alongside “Angel Band” and “Cry from the Cross.”
The copyright on the record is credited to “Buddy Dee,” a name that appears on several of the Stanleys’ Mercury sides from these years, and the catalog leaves the writer unlinked until that credit is settled. The song belongs to the run of sorrowful love ballads the brothers favored in the mid-1950s, sung in the tight duet style that the Mercury years are remembered for. A looser, faster reading survives from a 1956 radio session in Bristol, issued in 2004 as An Evening Long Ago, with Curley Lambert on mandolin and Ralph Mayo on fiddle. The studio side has since been anthologized on Angel Band: The Classic Mercury Recordings (1995) and The Complete Mercury Recordings (2003).