Old-Time Music and Bluegrass: A Shared Family Tree

Assisted by AI. Spot something off? Help us fix it.

In the spring of 1965, in Mount Airy, North Carolina, a college student from Chapel Hill knocked on the front door of a sixty-four-year-old retired highway grader named Thomas Jefferson Jarrell. The student carried a reel-to-reel tape recorder and a fiddle case. Jarrell — soft-spoken, gregarious, broad-faced — invited him in, poured him a drink, and over the next two days taught him several tunes from a repertoire Jarrell had been playing since 1915, much of it learned from his father Ben and his fiddling neighbors in the Round Peak community a few miles east of town. The student left with about an hour and a half of recordings and a hand-copy of three or four fiddle tunings.

The student was, depending on which version of this scene you have, Alan Jabbour or Mike Seeger or Ray Alden or Andy Cahan or one of a dozen other young revivalists who would, in the second half of the 1960s, find their way to Jarrell’s door. The scene happened, in some form, many times. What is common to all of those versions is what Jarrell did when the student left. He went back to playing the same music. He had not been retrieving an artifact for the visitor. He had been showing them what he played all the time.

This is the chapter — the un-numbered companion piece to the seven History chapters — about that music. It is not a chapter about how old-time became bluegrass. Chapter 1 covered that question, and even there the framing was wrong: old-time and bluegrass are siblings, not parent and child. The two traditions came out of the same Appalachian generation in the 1920s and 1930s, took different aesthetic choices in the late 1940s, and have run on parallel tracks for the eighty years since. The bluegrass chapters of this section have told one side of that story. This piece tells the other.

What old-time is

Old-time, as the working musicians and the audience and the magazine and the festival circuit use the term, is rural Southern string-band dance music. The standard ensemble is fiddle, banjo, and guitar; sometimes mandolin or upright bass joins. The fiddle plays the melody. The banjo, in clawhammer or frailing style — a down-stroke right hand that moves like a fan instead of a claw, the thumb dropping onto the drone string between beats — plays the same melody with rhythmic variation, or backs the fiddle with a chord-and-drum pattern called bum-ditty. The guitar holds bass-strum rhythm. Every instrument is either playing the tune or supporting it.

What old-time does not have, and never had, is the break-trading format that bluegrass adopted in 1945. Nobody in an old-time band stops playing while someone else takes a solo. There is no “kickoff” by a featured musician; there is no “lead” instrument in the rotating sense. The music is collective and continuous, more like a wheel turning than a relay race. The function it serves is the dance floor — square dances, breakdowns, contra dances, the fiddlers’ convention competitions where two musicians might play together for ten minutes without ever stopping. Tempos are usually slower than bluegrass, the feel less driving, the texture warmer and shaggier.

Sally Ann
Oscar Jenkins, Fred Cockerham, Tommy Jarrell — from Down to the Cider Mill (County 713), 1968
The Round Peak fiddle-banjo lock: Jarrell on fiddle, Cockerham on banjo, Jenkins on guitar. The listening reference for what old-time string-band music sounds like.

The repertoire is shared with bluegrass, mostly: “Soldier’s Joy,” “Cumberland Gap,” “Cripple Creek,” “Old Joe Clark,” “Sally Goodin,” “Bonaparte’s Retreat,” “Forked Deer,” “Cluck Old Hen.” The same fiddle tunes that Bill Monroe sped up and recorded with the Blue Grass Boys in 1946 had been circulating in the Appalachian string-band tradition for fifty years or more before he got to them. Old-time players still play them. They play them more or less the way the players who taught Bill Monroe’s generation had played them. Same tunes, different aesthetic priorities.

The fork

The two traditions parted ways around 1945. Chapter 1 has the long account of how Bill Monroe and the Blue Grass Boys, in the December after Earl Scruggs joined the band, started doing something to the older string-band template that nobody had quite done before: Scruggs’s three-finger banjo replaced the older clawhammer; the band traded breaks instead of playing the melody in unison; tempos went up to suit the stage rather than the dance floor; arrangements got tighter and more microphone-conscious; the vocal aesthetic moved toward what Mike Seeger would later, picking up a phrase from a different player, call the high lonesome sound. What old-time kept, by virtue of not following Monroe into those changes, was everything bluegrass left behind: clawhammer banjo, fiddle-led ensemble unison, the dance-floor function, the communal jam structure, the looser tempos, and the way a modal tune could ride its drone without anyone needing to call the chords.

The choice was less a moment than a slow divergence. The Galax Old Fiddlers’ Convention had been running annually in southwestern Virginia since 1935, ten years before Earl Scruggs walked onstage at the Ryman. The fiddlers and banjoists who had played the Galax stage in the 1930s and 1940s — Wade Ward, Crockett Ward, Kyle Creed, Tommy Jarrell, Fred Cockerham — were not waiting for bluegrass to happen so they could not become it. They were playing a kind of music that Bill Monroe’s stage band did not, exactly, replace.

What Monroe’s band did, commercially, was take the audience. By the late 1940s the major record labels had lost interest in old-time. The format that could fill a barn and chart on country radio was bluegrass, and after 1948 it was Flatt and Scruggs and the Stanley Brothers as well. The older string-band sound continued to exist, but for fifteen years it stopped being recorded by any institution other than the Library of Congress.

The music nobody was recording, 1945–1958

The years between the end of the war and the late 1950s are the period when the historical record almost lost the music. The 78-rpm boom of the 1920s and early 1930s had captured a thin slice — Charlie Poole and the North Carolina Ramblers’ tightly arranged string-band records for Columbia from 1925 onward, Gid Tanner and the Skillet Lickers from 1926, the Carter Family from 1927, the Stoneman Family, the Carolina Tar Heels, Dock Boggs’s six startling Brunswick sides from March 1927 — but most of the older string-band players had never been near a recording machine, and after the Depression even the commercial labels stopped trying to find them.

Gid Tanner and the Skillet Lickers, c.1926
Gid Tanner and his Skillet Lickers, c.1926 — the tightly-arranged Georgia string band whose mid-1920s Columbia sides defined what commercial old-time would sound like in the years before Bristol. Public domain via Wikimedia Commons
Don't Let Your Deal Go Down Blues
Charlie Poole and the North Carolina Ramblers — Columbia 15038-D, recorded July 27, 1925
The reference point for pre-bluegrass commercial string-band music — and the recording from which the urban folk revival would, twenty-five years later, work backward.
Learn it on Picker’s Guide

In Round Peak, North Carolina, and Galax, Virginia, and across the high country of southwest Virginia and east Kentucky, the music continued without commercial documentation. Tommy Jarrell, born March 1, 1901, was at home in Mount Airy playing weekend dances with his neighbor Fred Cockerham (born November 3, 1905). Kyle Creed (born May 26, 1912) was making banjos in Surry County. Wade Ward (born October 15, 1892) was driving down from Independence to the Galax fiddlers’ convention every August. House dances, church socials, county fairs — the music kept its function. It just lost its audience beyond the holler.

The institutional record-keepers were the only people paying attention. Alan Lomax, working for the Library of Congress’s Archive of American Folk Song, recorded Wade Ward at his home in Independence, Virginia, in 1937 and again on a 1941 field trip. Lomax recorded Texas Gladden, the Appalachian ballad singer from Salem, Virginia, on the same 1941 trip. The recordings sat in the Library of Congress collection for two decades, available to musicologists but not commercially released. What the major labels had decided not to look at, the federal government had, almost by accident, kept.

The point worth making here is that this is the period when old-time and bluegrass diverged not just musically but commercially. By 1955 there were dozens of working bluegrass bands recording for major labels and touring the country. There were no working old-time bands recording for major labels at all. The music had not stopped being played. It had stopped being heard.

The folk-revival rediscovery

The change started, structurally, in May 1952, when Folkways Records released Harry Smith’s Anthology of American Folk Music — six LPs of 1920s and 1930s 78-rpm reissues, curated by an eccentric San Francisco filmmaker and ethnographer named Harry Everett Smith, packaged with cryptic woodcut illustrations and dense biographical and interpretive liner notes. The Anthology became the urban folk revival’s textbook. For a generation of New York and Cambridge and Berkeley college students who had grown up after the war, it was the document that revealed what the music had sounded like before they were born. The records on it — Clarence Ashley, Dock Boggs, the Carter Family, Charlie Poole, Mississippi John Hurt, Cannon’s Jug Stompers, Buell Kazee, Bascom Lamar Lunsford — became, almost as a side effect of the Anthology’s curation, the working canon of what came to be called old-time music.


Dock Boggs portrait
Moran Lee 'Dock' Boggs — the Wise County, Virginia, coal-miner-banjoist whose six 1927 Brunswick sides ended his commercial career and, three decades later, restarted it via the Anthology of American Folk Music. Virginia State Parks via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY)

Roscoe Holcomb, c.1963
Roscoe Holcomb in Daisy, Kentucky, c.1963 — the banjoist John Cohen recorded on a Kentucky porch in 1959. His unguarded modal-pentatonic vocal style gave Cohen's 1962 film the phrase 'the high lonesome sound.' Library of Congress American Folklife Center

Country Blues
Dock Boggs — Brunswick 131-A, recorded March 1927
One of the six Boggs sides from his March 1927 sessions; included on the Anthology of American Folk Music and instrumental in the folk-revival generation's understanding of what pre-bluegrass banjo music sounded like.

What followed was less the rediscovery of a music than the deliberate construction of a relationship to it. In 1958, three young musicians in New York City — Mike Seeger (the younger half-brother of Pete Seeger, by then a fluent player of banjo and fiddle and autoharp and a meticulous student of the Anthology); John Cohen (a Yale-educated photographer and filmmaker who had been documenting the Beat Generation in Greenwich Village); and Tom Paley (a Yale-trained mathematician and an expert old-time banjoist) — formed a string band they called the New Lost City Ramblers. Their innovation was a method as much as a sound: they would learn the songs from the 78s, then go find the living source players and learn from them in person. Folkways released the New Lost City Ramblers’ self-titled debut LP in December 1958. Tom Paley left the band in 1962 and was replaced by Tracy Schwarz. The Ramblers recorded prolifically into the 1970s and dissolved as a working unit in 1979.

Mike Seeger, January 1964
Mike Seeger in 1964 — the younger half-brother of Pete and, with John Cohen and Tom Paley, the cofounder of the New Lost City Ramblers. The model revivalist: learn the songs from the 78s, then find the living players and learn from them in person. UCLA / LA Times Photographic Archive via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY)
Battleship of Maine
The New Lost City Ramblers — from The New Lost City Ramblers (Folkways FA 2396), December 1958
The band that modeled the revival's method — learn from the records, then find the players.

The find-the-players half of the method ran in parallel through the same years. In 1959 John Cohen drove to Daisy, Kentucky, looking for traditional banjo players. A local pointed him toward Roscoe Holcomb, a coal-miner and banjoist living in a cinder-block house outside town. Cohen recorded Holcomb on his porch. The recordings became Folkways LP FA 2317 in 1960, titled Mountain Music of Kentucky. Two years later Cohen made a short documentary about Holcomb called The High Lonesome Sound. The phrase came from the film’s title; Cohen had used it to describe Holcomb’s unguarded, modal-pentatonic vocal style. The same phrase, six years later, would be applied to bluegrass tenor singing by Mike Seeger in his 1959 Folkways liner notes for Mountain Music Bluegrass Style. The phrase originally referred to old-time.

A third discovery story unfolded in North Carolina in 1960. Ralph Rinzler — the folklorist who would later run the Newport Folk Festival’s folk-arts programming and direct the Smithsonian’s Folklife Festival — drove to an Old Time Fiddlers’ Convention looking for Clarence Ashley, the East Tennessee banjoist and singer who had recorded for Columbia in 1929 (his “The Coo Coo Bird” and “The House Carpenter” sides ran on the Anthology) and had been largely out of music for thirty years since. Rinzler found Ashley, persuaded him to take up the banjo again, and met in the process Ashley’s neighbor — a blind thirty-seven-year-old piano tuner from Deep Gap, North Carolina named Arthel “Doc” Watson, who was playing electric guitar in a local rockabilly band and did not own an acoustic. Rinzler convinced him to borrow one. Watson, Ashley, and the Watson family circle (Doc’s father-in-law Gaither Carlton, the neighbor Fred Price, Ashley’s son-in-law Clint Howard) made two Folkways LPs — Old Time Music at Clarence Ashley’s Volume One (FA 2355, 1961) and Volume Two (FA 2359, 1963). Friends of Old-Time Music brought the group to New York’s Town Hall in early 1961. Doc’s flatpicking — his arrangement of fiddle tunes on the guitar, his clean melodic line, his blues-and-gospel-inflected reading of the Appalachian repertoire — became, over the half-century that followed, the foundational vocabulary for acoustic-guitar players in both old-time and bluegrass; the line runs through Norman Blake, Tony Rice, Russ Barenberg, and Bryan Sutton. Watson died in 2012, at eighty-nine.

Mike Seeger, traveling separately through southwest Virginia in 1963, found Moran Lee “Dock” Boggs in Wise County, where Boggs had been working as a coal miner since 1929 — the year his recording career had ended. Seeger persuaded him to play again. Boggs’s first Folkways LP, recorded in 1964 at the age of sixty-five, restarted his musical life. The Friends of Old Time Music — a concert series organized in New York between 1961 and 1965 by Cohen, Israel Young, Ralph Rinzler, and Peter Siegel — brought tradition-bearers north for the first time. Roscoe Holcomb performed at NYC Town Hall. So did Bill Monroe. The music that had stopped being commercial in 1945 became, in the early 1960s, a working folklore archive that played live concerts.

The temptation in describing this period — and a misconception worth naming directly — is to call what the revivalists did saving the music. The music was not dying. Tommy Jarrell was alive and playing in Mount Airy. Wade Ward was alive and playing in Galax. Roscoe Holcomb was alive and playing in Daisy, Kentucky. What the revivalists did was learn the music, record it for an urban audience that had never heard it, and re-amplify it through Folkways LPs and Town Hall concerts. They did not invent the music or rescue it or originate it. They became its students.

Round Peak becomes the canon

By the mid-1960s, the revival had picked a canon. Of all the regional Appalachian styles still alive in 1965 — east Kentucky thumb-style banjo (Hobart Smith, Roscoe Holcomb); West Virginia fiddling (Burl Hammons and the broader Hammons family); Appalachian Ohio (Henry Reed, whose tunes Alan Jabbour would transcribe and document); middle Tennessee (Uncle Dave Macon’s grandchildren); the Texas fiddle tradition; the Cape Breton-derived New England tradition — one regional style became the urban revival’s default. The mountain just east of Mount Airy, North Carolina, where the Blue Ridge Parkway crosses the Virginia line: Round Peak.

The reasons were partly geographic and partly accidental. Mount Airy was a four-hour drive from Chapel Hill, six from Washington, eight from New York. The source players — Jarrell, Cockerham, Creed, Ward in nearby Galax, the Jenkins brothers, the Camp Creek Boys — were generous with their time and unusually willing to teach. The regional style itself was unusually tight and rhythmically locked, the clawhammer banjo and fiddle interlocking in a way that the urban-revival learners could pick up by ear in a weekend. And Mike Seeger, Eric Davidson, Caleb Finch, and the small County Records label, founded in New York City in 1963, began documenting Round Peak in a sustained way from the late 1960s onward. By 1972 there were Tommy Jarrell LPs on County and Rounder. By 1975 there were Camp Creek Boys LPs. The recordings circulated. The repertoire moved into the classrooms.

What this meant, structurally, is worth saying carefully. Round Peak became the revival’s default old-time sound by the early 1970s — the regional style that most new learners encountered first. But Round Peak is not, and never was, the only old-time tradition. The east Kentucky thumb-style of Hobart Smith and Roscoe Holcomb, the modal West Virginia fiddling of the Hammons family, the Henry Reed tradition of Appalachian Ohio, the Cape Breton Scottish tradition still preserved in Maritime Canada — all were equally living, equally documentable, equally available to the revival if it had reached for them more aggressively. That the revival reached for Round Peak first was an accident of geography and the generosity of a handful of source players. The bias has persisted into the contemporary scene. Cecelia Conway’s African Banjo Echoes in Appalachia (University of Tennessee Press, 1995), the foundational scholarly text on the African origins of clawhammer technique, made the obvious larger point: the all-white Round Peak canon partially obscured the Black musical traditions that had shaped clawhammer banjo in the first place. The scene’s twenty-first-century diversification, when it came, would have to find its way back to the parts of the tradition the revival had not catalogued.

Tommy Jarrell died on January 28, 1985, at eighty-three. Fred Cockerham had died on July 8, 1980. Kyle Creed in November 1982. Wade Ward had died on May 29, 1971, before the revival’s center of gravity had fully settled on Round Peak. Their students kept playing. The records they had made stayed in print.

The urban revival bands of the 1970s

The students started forming bands. Most ran on the same engine: city-raised musicians, conservatory-educated or close to it, deliberately studying Round Peak and Galax repertoire, playing for contradances and folk festivals along the East Coast circuit. The bands were not commercial in the IBMA sense — most of the members held day jobs, often academic ones — but they made records and built audiences and taught the next generation of learners how to play.

The Hollow Rock String Band was formed in Durham, North Carolina, in 1968, around Tommy Thompson, his then-wife Bobbie Thompson, and Alan Jabbour. Jabbour was, by training and inclination, the band’s scholar; he would, by the mid-1970s, head the Folk Arts division of the National Endowment for the Arts and later the American Folklife Center at the Library of Congress. The Hollow Rock LP, Traditional Dance Tunes, released on Kanawha Records in 1968, was an early model of the revival’s musicological-rigor mode — careful, accurate, deeply researched. The Fuzzy Mountain String Band, also Durham-based, formed around the same time with Bill Hicks and Bertram Levy and a rotating cast; their two Rounder LPs in 1972 and 1973 catalogued Round Peak repertoire for the broader revival audience.

Betty Likens
The Hollow Rock String Band — from Traditional Dance Tunes (Kanawha 311), 1968
The Durham musicological mode; an old-time band led, in part, by the scholar (Alan Jabbour) who would later run the National Endowment for the Arts' folk-arts division.
Learn it on Picker’s Guide

The Highwoods String Band — formed in 1972 in Trumansburg, New York, near Ithaca — was the opposite temperament. Walt Koken, Mac Benford, Bob Potts, Jenny Cleland, and Doug Dorschug were raucous, loud, dance-driven; closer to the spirit of a 1920s Charlie Poole session than the Hollow Rock musicological mode. Their three Rounder LPs from 1973 through 1977 — Fire on the Mountain (1973), Dance All Night (1975), and No. 3 Special (1977) — were, for a long stretch of the 1970s, the records that taught most new old-time players outside the South what the music could sound like in a working ensemble. The Red Clay Ramblers, formed in Chapel Hill the same year (1972), around Tommy Thompson moving over from Hollow Rock, Jim Watson, Bill Hicks, and later Mike Craver and Jack Herrick, drifted out of pure old-time into music theater and broader Americana. They eventually scored Sam Shepard plays.

Fire on the Mountain
The Highwoods String Band — title track from Fire on the Mountain (Rounder), 1973
The raucous urban-revival counterpart to Durham's musicological mode; the band that taught most non-Southern players what an old-time string band could sound like with the room turned up.

The New Lost City Ramblers themselves continued through 1979, recording occasional Folkways LPs and touring as long as the original lineup held together. Their model — learn from the records, find the players — by the mid-1970s had passed into the entire revival’s working method. The revival had become, in some structural sense, its own institution.

Alongside the urban revival bands, the same Folkways-and-Rounder infrastructure brought rural Appalachian tradition-bearers — many of whom had been performing for decades on local radio and at regional gatherings — to national audiences. Ola Belle Reed was the most influential of these. Born in 1916 in Lansing, North Carolina, in the Ashe County mountain country where her family had played music for generations, she moved north with her family during the Depression and spent most of her adult life along the Maryland-Pennsylvania border, where she ran a country music park with her husband Bud and broadcast for years on regional radio. Her 1973 Rounder LP Ola Belle Reed introduced a national audience to her songwriting voice, her clawhammer banjo, and the body of original songs that would eventually carry her work into the bluegrass repertoire — most famously through Del McCoury’s recording of her “High on a Mountain,” now a bluegrass standard. The National Endowment for the Arts named her a National Heritage Fellow in 1986. She is connective tissue between the rural Appalachian song tradition and the wider American canon — old-time by training, songwriter by inclination, performer by long habit.

The same era also brought to wider audiences Hazel Dickens and Alice Gerrard, who began recording together as a duo on the 1965 Folkways LP Who’s That Knocking? and continued through several Rounder records in the 1970s. The Hazel & Alice records sat squarely in the old-time-and-folk borderlands the revival had opened up — tight duet harmony on mostly older repertoire, the sound of two women working a tradition that had largely been recorded by men. Dickens’s broader bluegrass-singer-and-songwriter career, which made her one of the most-recorded songwriters in the music, is taken up at length in the Grows Up chapter.

What had also happened by 1975 was a different kind of institutional formation. The festival circuit, which the bluegrass world had been building since Carlton Haney’s Fincastle weekend in 1965, found a parallel in the old-time world. The Mount Airy Bluegrass and Old-Time Fiddlers’ Convention started in 1972 in Surry County, North Carolina — the same county where Tommy Jarrell had been teaching the revivalists for the previous five years. The Brandywine Mountain Music Convention began the same year, in Delaware and Maryland. The Galax fiddlers’ convention, by then almost forty years old, expanded its old-time competition categories and became the scene’s annual reunion. Augusta Heritage Center, the long-running summer instructional camp at Davis & Elkins College in Elkins, West Virginia, was founded in 1973 and became, over the next four decades, the central node for the teacher-student transmission that kept the music going.

Clifftop and the festival economy

The scene’s modern center of gravity is a four-day camping festival at Camp Washington-Carver in Clifftop, West Virginia. The Appalachian String Band Music Festival there was founded by the West Virginia Department of Arts, Culture and History in 1989; the first festival ran in August 1990. Late-July or early-August timing has remained constant. Attendance grew from a few hundred in the early 1990s to several thousand by the 2010s. It is, by general agreement among the scene’s working musicians, the closest thing modern old-time has to a capital city.

Galax (running since 1935) and Mount Airy (since 1972) remained the older festival anchors, both retaining a mixed bluegrass and old-time character with separate competition categories. Clifftop was the first major festival that was entirely old-time, and its calendar slot — the first week of August, in most years — became the scene’s annual gathering. By the late 2000s, the typical Clifftop weekend was a recognizable culture: daytime workshops and contest sets on the main stage; nights filled with jamming in the campground, fires lit, fiddles unpacked, players moving from one circle to the next until dawn. The repertoire is shared by ear; nobody hands out chord charts. The social mode is non-hierarchical to the point of folklore — Bruce Molsky, one of the contemporary scene’s most widely admired fiddlers, and a first-time camper might be in the same jam circle at two in the morning.

What the festival circuit gave the old-time scene, structurally, was the same thing the bluegrass festival circuit had given bluegrass after 1965: an economic backbone independent of the commercial recording industry. The revival-era bands had never been able to make a living from their records — most had supplemented their income with day jobs. The festival circuit changed that, partly. By the 1990s a working old-time musician could plan the year around the festivals: Clifftop in early August, Galax in mid-August, Mount Airy in early June, the Brandywine in July, the regional fall festivals through October. None of this paid as well as the bluegrass-festival circuit did. But it kept the music going, and it kept the teaching going, and it gave the scene a calendar.

The 2000s and the music now

Two large shifts in the last twenty-five years.

The first is the broadening of who plays. In April 2005, the Black Banjo Gathering convened at Appalachian State University in Boone, North Carolina, organized by Cecelia Conway and Sule Greg Wilson. Joe Thompson, the eighty-six-year-old fiddler from Mebane, North Carolina who had kept his family’s string-band tradition alive through seven decades, played; Mike Seeger attended. Three young musicians who would form a band together met at the gathering: Rhiannon Giddens (a North Carolina-born singer and banjoist trained at Oberlin), Dom Flemons (an Arizona-born multi-instrumentalist of broad repertoire), and Justin Robinson. They formed the Carolina Chocolate Drops, apprenticed with Joe Thompson at his Mebane porch every week from 2005 onward until his death in February 2012, and recorded for Music Maker Relief Foundation and then Nonesuch. Their album Genuine Negro Jig won the Grammy for Best Traditional Folk Album in 2011. Giddens went on to win the Pulitzer Prize for Music in 2023, for her opera Omar (co-composed with Michael Abels). Flemons built a long solo career as the American Songster.

Cornbread and Butterbeans
Carolina Chocolate Drops — from Genuine Negro Jig (Nonesuch), 2010
The Grammy-winning record from the band's apprenticeship years with Joe Thompson.

The Chocolate Drops brought a body of older string-band material back into the contemporary scene’s working repertoire — songs and instrumental pieces that had been documented in Cecelia Conway’s African Banjo Echoes in Appalachia (1995) but had largely fallen out of revival-era circulation. The records and the touring band influenced a younger generation of multi-tradition players who came up after them.

The second large shift is the emergence of a contemporary master-player generation. Bruce Molsky, born in New York City in 1955 and raised in the Bronx, is one of the contemporary scene’s most widely admired fiddlers — with a repertoire stretching from Round Peak through Cape Breton to the Scandinavian fiddle traditions; he is a visiting scholar in the American Roots Music Program at Berklee College of Music. Dirk Powell, born in Ohio in 1968 and raised in Kentucky, brings a Cajun-influenced sensibility to his work; he has played on the Cold Mountain soundtrack. Rayna Gellert, born in 1971 in Indiana and raised in North Carolina, was a member of Uncle Earl — the all-woman old-time band of 2000s with KC Groves, Abigail Washburn, and Kristin Andreassen — and has built a long solo career since. The Foghorn Stringband, formed in Portland, Oregon in 2000 around Stephen “Sammy” Lind, Caleb Klauder, Reeb Willms, and Nadine Landry, plays hot, dance-driven old-time from the West Coast.

The Old-Time Herald, the scene’s trade press, was founded in 1987 and edited for many years by Alice Gerrard. The Augusta Heritage Center continues. The regional schools remain alive: Round Peak (now led by the second generation of revivalists), Galax and the broader Surry County tradition, the Bruce Greene-anchored Kentucky tradition, West Virginia (the Hammons family’s repertoire as preserved by their students), Appalachian Ohio (Henry Reed’s tunes carried on by Alan Jabbour’s transcriptions). Old-time today is still primarily a festival-and-jam economy; still tradition-bearer-to-student in transmission; increasingly inclusive in who shows up; still distinct from bluegrass in temperament — slower, quieter, no break-trading, the jam circle as the basic social unit rather than the stage.

What it is not is a rediscovered music. The rediscovery happened in 1960. What it has been doing for the sixty-five years since is living.


The visitors stopped coming to Tommy Jarrell’s house when he died in 1985. By then, the visitors had become teachers themselves, and the music had spread far enough that it didn’t need a single source location anymore. The Round Peak repertoire is now played widely across North America and Europe. The Carolina Chocolate Drops’ work brought Joe Thompson’s family tradition into the broader contemporary scene; Rhiannon Giddens later took her work into opera and won a Pulitzer for it. Bruce Molsky teaches at Berklee. The Foghorn Stringband headlines Pacific Northwest dance halls. The festival in Clifftop, every August, draws several thousand musicians from across the country and many from beyond it.

Bluegrass and old-time are siblings born of the same Appalachian generation in the same set of mountain communities. They grew up to choose different lives. Bluegrass went to Nashville, learned to wear a suit, learned the microphone, kept getting faster. Old-time stayed home, kept the dance floor, played at the same tempos it had been playing in 1925, and waited for the world to come find it. The world did. The world keeps coming.


Sources and further reading

  • Cecelia Conway, African Banjo Echoes in Appalachia: A Study of Folk Traditions (University of Tennessee Press, 1995). The foundational scholarly text on the banjo’s African origins and the Black-and-white shared-tradition history.
  • Phil Jamison, Hoedowns, Reels, and Frolics: Roots and Branches of Southern Appalachian Dance (University of Illinois Press, 2015). The standing reference on the dance-music function that anchored Round Peak and the old-time tradition more broadly.
  • Robert Cantwell, When We Were Good: The Folk Revival (Harvard University Press, 1996). The cultural interior of the revival.
  • Benjamin Filene, Romancing the Folk: Public Memory and American Roots Music (University of North Carolina Press, 2000). The politics of authenticity that drove the rediscovery period.
  • Bill C. Malone, Country Music, U.S.A. (University of Texas Press, 1968; rev. eds. through 2010). The standing reference history of country music, with substantial treatment of the pre-bluegrass string-band era.
  • The Old-Time Herald magazine archive — the scene’s trade press since 1987.
  • The County Records catalog of Round Peak and other revival-era documentary recordings.
  • Smithsonian Folkways Recordings — for the New Lost City Ramblers, Mike Seeger field recordings, Roscoe Holcomb, Dock Boggs, and the broader Anthology lineage.

Roulette Settings

Calculating…
Popularity
Type
Genres
Bluegrass
Folk
Country
Old-Time
Other
Popularity
Difficulty
Type
Key
Featured Instruments
Origin

Share Playlist